The Colts are “essentially” undefeated entering Super Bowl XLIV, but had they made half an effort, there would be no asterisk next to the word perfection for them. Ignore that (16-2) thing by their team name, because the Jets and Bills were given gift wins late in the year when Curtis Painter played like a high school house painter. Peyton Manning in a headset is the only reason we aren’t anticipating the second 19-0 attempt in three years, and that is a shame.
But my feeling is that it’s not a shame that they simply aren’t undefeated. I’m not a Colts fan, so them being 19-0 isn’t an issue for me. But it’s the fact that their 16-2 record is deceiving and by the same token, their laying down tactic allowed one team to sneak into the playoffs — the same team the Colts got to dust away in the AFC Championship Game. Essentially, a potential Chargers-Colts showdown never occurred because the Chargers took the Jets way too lightly, the same Jets that rallied against Painter and the hapless Colts reserves in Week 16.
What is also a shame is that they are not chasing perfection as a result of their own decision, not a genuine defeat. Had they lost to Jacksonville in a hard-fought Week 15 game, we would’ve given the Jaguars their due dilligence for beating a Colts team playing at full strength and playing to win. But enter Painter, and enter despair.
Now I feel for the rookie in this unfortunate position, but he is in the limelight because Jim Caldwell didn’t want to risk anything despite being 14-0. When we look back at the 2009 Colts championship season, we can’t help but simply say “yeah but” when looking at those L’s next to the Jets and Bills games. For shame.